RSS

Should You Buy or Sell First?

Should You Buy or Sell First?

If you already own a home and you’re thinking about moving, one of the first questions that usually comes up is also one of the hardest to answer:

Do I buy first, or sell first?

There isn’t one right answer for everyone. The better choice depends on your finances, the current market, how specific your next-home search is, how much flexibility you have with timing, and how comfortable you are carrying some uncertainty.

What matters most is understanding the trade-offs before you make the decision.

Buying First

Buying first can make a lot of sense if finding the right next home is going to take time.

Maybe you are looking in a very specific neighbourhood. Maybe you need a certain layout, school district, lot, garage or number of bedrooms. If the right properties do not come up very often, buying first gives you the freedom to wait for something that genuinely works rather than feeling pressured to choose whatever is available because your current home has already sold.

It can also make the transition between homes feel easier. You know where you are going, you can plan possession dates, and you are not trying to find a new home while the clock is ticking on your sale.

The challenge, of course, is financial.

Buying first may mean carrying two properties for a period of time, arranging bridge financing, or making an offer that is conditional on the sale of your existing home. Whether any of those options are realistic depends on your financial situation and the lender involved.

That is why I want my clients to speak with their mortgage professional before we decide on this route. We need to know what is possible before we start writing offers.

Selling First

Selling first gives you certainty.

Once your home is sold, you know exactly how much equity you are working with and you are no longer guessing about what your current home may sell for. That can make budgeting for the next purchase much easier.

It also means you are not carrying two homes at once.

For some buyers, that financial peace of mind is worth a lot.

The trade-off is that once your home sells, there is now a timeline attached to your search. If possession is approaching and we have not found the right property yet, you may need to make temporary housing arrangements or be more flexible about what you buy.

That is not necessarily a problem, but it is something we should plan for before putting your home on the market.

What Is the Market Doing?

The market can influence which strategy makes more sense.

If homes like yours are selling quickly but the type of property you want to buy is harder to find, buying first may be worth considering.

If your current home could take longer to sell, selling first may reduce the risk of owning two properties for longer than you intended.

And sometimes the market is balanced enough that we can coordinate both sides fairly closely.

This is one of the reasons I do not like giving buyers and sellers a blanket answer to this question. The right strategy can change depending on the market, the property and your personal situation.

How Specific Is Your Next Home?

This is a big one.

If you are moving because you simply want a little more space and you are open to several communities, layouts and styles of home, you may have plenty of options once your current property sells.

But if your wish list is very specific, the search may take longer.

Maybe you need a triple garage. Maybe you want to stay within one school boundary. Maybe you need a main-floor office, a certain commute or a particular lot orientation.

The more specific the search, the more important it becomes to think carefully about selling first and putting yourself on a deadline.

Could You Handle a Gap Between Homes?

This is one of the most useful questions to ask yourself.

If your home sells and the right next property has not come along yet, would you be comfortable renting temporarily? Staying with family? Putting some belongings into storage?

For some people, that is completely manageable.

For others, the idea of moving twice makes selling first feel far less appealing.

Neither answer is wrong. It is simply part of figuring out which option fits you best.

Possession Dates Can Help

Buying and selling do not always have to happen on exactly the same day.

Sometimes we can negotiate possession dates that give you a little extra breathing room between the two transactions. A longer possession on your sale or a carefully chosen possession date on your purchase can make the transition much smoother.

There are limits to how much timing we can control, especially when other buyers and sellers are involved, but possession dates are an important part of the strategy.

What About a Sale-of-Buyer’s-Home Condition?

In some situations, a buyer may write an offer that is conditional on selling their existing home.

That can reduce some of the financial risk of buying first, but it also makes the offer more complicated for the seller. In a competitive situation, a seller may prefer an offer that does not depend on another property selling.

Whether this type of condition makes sense depends on the property, the market and the amount of competition.

It is an option, not an automatic solution.

So, Which Should You Do?

Before making the decision, I usually want to understand three things:

What is your current home likely to sell for and how long could that take?

How difficult is it likely to be to find the home you want to buy?

And financially, how much flexibility do you realistically have between the two transactions?

Once we know those answers, the decision becomes much clearer.

For some clients, selling first gives them the certainty they need. For others, finding the right next home is the bigger priority, so buying first makes more sense.

The goal is not to follow a rule. It is to build a plan around your situation.

If you are thinking about selling your current home and buying another one in Calgary, we can look at both sides of the move before you commit to either. That way, you know what the options are, what the risks are, and what strategy gives you the most flexibility.

Data is supplied by Pillar 9™ MLS® System. Pillar 9™ is the owner of the copyright in its MLS®System. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by Pillar 9™.
The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Used under license.